Bathtub Refinishing vs. Tub Liners: Which Is Best?
When a bathtub becomes worn out or its style and color are no longer desirable, most people would prefer a complete replacement. However, bathtub and shower replacements can be expensive, messy, and challenging. That’s why these alternatives exist: bathtub refinishing and tub liners. These options cater to homeowners who desire a renewed bathtub without the high cost or hassle of a complete replacement.
What is Bathtub Refinishing
Bathtub refinishing is the process of restoring the surface of a tub to its original condition or modifying it for improved aesthetic appeal. The most common types of bathtub refinishing are acrylic, enamel, and epoxy coating. With proper preparation and application, this process can improve the appearance of your bathroom significantly.
What Are Bathtub Liners
Bathtub liners are a great way to give your bathtub an instant facelift. A bathtub liner is a thin sheet of acrylic or vinyl that is custom fit and placed securely over the existing tub, giving it a fresh new look in just one day.
These liners provide excellent protection against chips, cracks and other damage while also hiding the signs of previous use. They also provide a superior seal against water (only usually vulnerable at the caulk lines), making it much easier to keep your bathtub clean and looking great.
Bathtub Refinishing Pros and Cons
Refinishing your bathtub can be a beneficial and cost-effective way to give it a much needed facelift, but there are some important considerations to take into account before starting the process. Here, we break down the pros and cons of bathtub refinishing.
Pros
- No demolition: Refinishing your bathtub eliminates the need for demolition work, so there’s no need to tear out the existing tub and dispose of it.
- Peripheral areas (like countertops) can be refinished: Refinishing your bathtub doesn’t have to mean just the tub itself; other peripheral areas, such as countertops, can also be refinished for a more complete look.
- Cost: It’s much more affordable than replacing your tub, which can be very expensive and time-consuming.
- Customize your tub: Customize to fit any aesthetic, whether you want a traditional white finish, a bright color, or something unique and sophisticated, refinishing gives you lots of options to make your bathroom the perfect space for relaxation.
Cons
- Odor and overspray during finishing: The process of refinishing a bathtub emits odors and produces overspray that may linger after the process is finished unless it is done by a professional company such as Tub Coaters that uses top notch materials that result in very little smell.
- Glazing may chip and peel: As time goes on, glaze applied during refinishing may start to chip and peel away unless it is done by a professional refinisher. Many handymen use cheap coatings that do not last and often begin to chip and a peel immediately after the coating is applied.
- Glazing covers over tile grout: Refinishing a bathtub may cover up damaged tile grout, making the need for repair or replacement. This is only true however, if the proper preparation is not done in re-grouting prior to the refinishing. If a professional company does your refinishing, this should not be a problem
- Special cleaners and cleaning techniques required: Cleaners used on refinished surfaces must not include bleach or scratch powders like comet or ajax; certain cleaning techniques should also be avoided in order to protect the finish, but these same techniques should be used on just about any tub to insure the longest life-span possible without premature damage.
If you decide that a bathtub refinishing is the right choice for you, make sure to do your research and find a qualified professional to recoat it. This will help in the long run!
Bathtub Liners Pros and Cons
Bathtub liners are a great way to give your bathtub a facelift with minimal disruption. It’s an less expensive option if you don’t want to go through the hassle of replacing your tub. Here, we’ll take a look at the pros and cons of installing bathtub liners so you can make an informed decision about whether it’s right for you.
Pros:
- No demolition is necessary when you install a bathtub liner, and no disposal of the old tub is required.
- The existing tub remains in place, with no overspray or odor from paint or other materials used during refinishing.
- No nasty odors or overspray’s
- Your tub will be ready for use immediately after installation.
Cons:
- Water can sometimes get trapped under the liner which may lead to mold growth.
- Installing a bathtub liner can reduce the space in the bathtub, and may cause the floor to flex due to weight changes.
- Proper installation is also necessary for a bathtub liner, so you must ensure that it is done professionally.
- Lastly, bathtub liners could be 5-10 times the cost of refinishing your tub.
If you decide that a bathtub liner is the right choice for you, make sure to do your research and find a qualified professional to install it. This will save you time, money and headaches in the long run!
What Is The Price Difference Between Bathtub Liners And Bathtub Refinishing?
Bathtub Liners are significantly more expensive than Bathtub refinishing overall due to the materials needed for installation. Both take about the same time to install/recoat, but the main benefit of using a liner is that it provides slightly faster turnaround time to use the tub.
When it comes to bathtub refinishing, there is a range of prices depending on the type of finish used and any additional features you choose to add. Refinishing can cost anywhere from $500 to $850, with the average cost being around $675. Refinishing also is done in one day and the dry time can be as little as a few hours. However, refinishing can be a great option if you’re looking for a more permanent solution that won’t require additional installation costs down the road.
How Much Time Does It Take To Install A Bathtub Liner?
The amount of time it takes to install a bathtub liner will depend on the size, shape, and configuration of your bathtub. Generally speaking, it can take anywhere from four to six hours to properly install a bathtub liner. The installation process typically requires preparing the existing surface before installation as well as adhering the new liner into place.
In order to ensure a proper installation, it is important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions and use all recommended tools and materials. Additionally, safety precautions should be taken at all times using protective gloves, a respirator mask, and safety glasses. It’s also important to make sure that the area in which you are working is well ventilated since certain adhesives may emit fumes during installation.
How Long Does It Take To Refinish A Bathtub?
Refinishing a bathtub typically takes 4-5 hours depending on the extent of repair needed. The process involves removing any existing liners, applying a de-glosser orstripper, sanding the surface, and then applying a new coat of tub liner material. After the recoating has been applied and dried, it will be sealed by the protective topcoat to protect against moisture and future damage.
Refinishing a bathtub is a great way to bring an old, dull tub back to life and increase the value of your home.
Which Is Right For You?
When it comes down to it, it’s up to you to decide which option is the best for your bathroom renovation. Both bathtub liners and refinishing have their own advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important to evaluate each one carefully before making a decision.
If you’re looking for a cost-effective solution that will give your bathroom an instant makeover, then either can be an option for you. However, if you’re looking to customize your tub and give it a fresh new look without spending a fortune, then refinishing is the way to go. Ultimately, it all comes down to what works best for you and your budget.
Hire A Professional
Need help installing a bathtub liner or help with bathtub refinishing? Fortunately, Tub Coaters is here and available to provide assistance with your refinishing needs. We are here to assist you with all aspects of the installation process.
Our team of professionals are highly experienced and skilled. We offer competitive pricing for our services, and we’ll make sure to meet your requirements while also staying within your budget. Contact us today to get started on transforming your bathroom!
